Johann Ludwig Krebs’ Clavier-Übung is a short essay in late eighteenth century chorale technique by an accomplished student of J.S. Bach. Each of the thirteen chorale tunes is given a short, witty Praeambulum, followed by a straightforward cantus firmus setting, and finally a bold four-part harmonization. While it might be easy to dismiss this music as so much post-Baroque fluff, the truth is that Krebs commanded a marvelously colorful sense of style, with admirable melodic invention and harmonic flair. The music ranges from the delightfully gallant, to the truly heartfelt.
Johann Ludwig Krebs is perhaps one of the best known of old Bach’s students. His style is generally more conservative than that of Bach’s more forward-looking and creative sons, and though he produced chamber music, and a few orchestral and choral works, the center of gravity for his output is certainly the music for organ, an inherently conservative genre. The Clavier-Übung presented here is the first part of a three-volume production: The first is chorale settings, the second is a suite, and the third is comprised of six sonatinas- the whole published in Nuremberg in the 1750s. Parts I and III are available in modern editions; Part II evidently has not been revived.
There are at least two previous recordings of the first part (the earlier from the mid 60s on Musica Sacra, and a more recent set from K617. There is also an ongoing set of the complete organ works from Querstand (not reviewed here, as far as I know). Though I haven’t heard these, I have no qualms in recommending William Porter’s recording with warm words. Porter was one of the earliest recipients of the Erwin Bodky prize for excellence in the performance of early music (30 years ago, in 1971-the curious can see the list of recipients, many now internationally famous, at www.csem.org/bodky.html). And he has been an ornament for the riche early-music scene in Boston for a decade or so, where he is on the faculty of the New England Conservatory. I have fond memories of a chamber-music concert there pairing David Douglas and Porter. Porter marries technical prowess and absolute clarity of line with a deep sense of the expressive possibilities of the music before him. In other hands this music might not be so compelling or captivating. But Porter makes the best of cases for it. He is helped by a marvelously clear and present recording of a characterful Swedish organ (from 1806 by Pehr Schörlin), lyrical in the individual stops and powerful in the pleno. All in all, a model for organ recordings. A fine disc, which should be of wide interest.
-Fanfare January 2002
The KrebsClavier-Übung (1752-53) is a collection of 39 pieces based on 13 familiar German chorales, each triple in the form Praeambulum-Chorale- Chorale alio modo, the "Chorale" being actually a chorale-prelude in the form of a bicinium or tricinium. In some instances the Praeambulum is the onlgest and most elaborate of the movements; in others it has the feelings of a genuine prelude to what follows. One hears echoes of Krebs' mentor, J.S. Bach, but these pieces have intrinsic interest, vitality, and originality. All of the movements are suitable for parish use, whether in the tripartite form or excerpted.
The recordings was made on the II/32 1806 Pehr Schiörlin organ (restored 1948 and 1996) in Gammalkil, Sweden, a gem in tonal quality and intimacy. Bill Porter plays with consummate mastery and displays the solo and ensemble colors of the organ to admirable effect. Complete registrations are given in the liner notes. According to the notes, the microphone placement was carefully balanced; the result is most effective sound.
-The Journal of the Association of Anglican Musicians October 2001
"Fascinating Krebs in Gammalkil"
"The performance is convincing, sensitive, and restrained, all details and ornaments chiseled with the utmost care. Very enjoyable!
--- In this recording, the beautiful sound and high quality of the Gammalkil organ is at last given full justice. We find here as exquisite blend of improvisation, chamber music, and church music.
Most instrumentalists, when they make a CD recording, do so because of a desire to record a particular part of the repertoire. An organist, however, is faced with an additional choice: the choice of an instrument. Which choice comes first is sometimes a matter of circumstance. In the case of this recording, the circumstance was that of encountering an organ of almost magical beauty nestled in the rolling farmlands of eastern Sweden. The extraordinary tonal character of this instrument points the organist in two directions: on the one hand its strong, reedy ensemble is ideal for congregational singing on the other hand it possesses a wealth of highly colorful flute and string registers of intense sweetness that also invite the organist to improvise. This is hardly surprising, since the organs of Pehr Schiörlin were intended for just such a dual use. In the case of the instrument at Gammalkil, Schiörlin’s largest, its internal layout, wind system, and its pipework all combine to produce a highly melodic organ, appropriate for polyphony provided that the texture is not too thick (duos and trios work especially well), but ideal for the simple expressivity of much of the organ music of the mid-eighteenth century and later.
Accordingly, the Clavier-Übung of Johann Ludwig Krebs, published in two volumes in 1752 and 1753, provides ample material to bring the organ’s tonal resources to life, and the organ reciprocates by clothing these pieces with gesture, speech, and melodic charm. The Clavier-Übung is a collection of 39 pieces based upon 13 chorales in standard use in the eighteenth century. Each chorale is given a Praeambulum, followed by either a bicinium or tricinium, and concludes with a figured bass harmonization of the chorale. The two- and three-part settings allow the “chamber music” registrations of the Gammalkil organ to be heard to good effect, and they reflect the improvisational style of their era, while the concluding harmonizations allow for a display of the various ways in which this organ produces sounds for congregational singing.
In addition to the Clavier-Übung, the two chorale preludes “Von Gott will ich nicht lassen” and “Herzlich lieb hab ich dich, o Herr,” were among the favorites of the late Carl-Gustaf Lewenhaupt, who supervised the organ’s recent restoration; it is to his memory that this recording is dedicated, with deep gratitude for his life and work.
– William Porter
The Composer
“The bearer, Mr. Johann Ludwig Krebs, [is] one who has so distinguished himself here particularly ‘in musicis,’ having qualified himself in respect to the clavier, the violin, and the lute, as well as composition…I wish him accordingly Divine Support in his advancement, and herewith recommend him again most heartily.”
- The New Bach Reader, ed. David, Mendel, Wolff
With these words Johann Sebastian Bach recommended one of his prized pupils. Especially noteworthy is his use of the words “in musicis”—a special term used by Bach to indicate those students who understood music at an intuitive level. Krebs’s connection with Bach was a deep one; Johann Ludwig's father had also studied organ with Bach when at Weimar. As part of Bach’s inner circle for nine years, Krebs learned a variety of musical skills and undoubtedly performed on the organ, harpsichord, violin, and lute in many performances led by Bach. Many of Bach’s compositions have come down to us in Krebs’s hand, including cantatas 142 (“Nun danket”) and 140 (“Wachet auf”) and a number of organ works. Following his studies with Bach in Leipzig Krebs went on to hold three successive positions as organist: at the Marienkirche of Zwickau, at the castle in Zeitz, and at the castle in Altenburg. At Altenburg he presided over the large Trost organ of 1739 in the castle’s chapel, an instrument whose silvery elegant sounds cause organists to marvel to this day. He stayed there for forty-five years until his death at the age of eighty-six.
Although it is impossible today to view Krebs outside of the shadow of his musical mentor, Krebs established an independent reputation as a virtuoso organist, organ expert, and organ teacher. When Bach died, Krebs was immediately considered as his possible successor at Leipzig. Like Bach, Krebs perpetuated his career through his children: his son succeeded him as organist in Altenburg, as did his grandson.
– Roger Sherman
About the Recording
The organ of Gammalkil, Sweden, is located in the rear gallery of the church, close to a curved, wooden, barrel-vaulted ceiling. The opposite end of the church is also curved and acoustically reflective. The church is made of stone and covered with plaster on the interior. These properties are ideal for the organ and for congregational singing, but present challenges to the recording engineer. Curved reflective surfaces can change the apparent direction of the sound in a stereo recording, creating a confusing stereo image. The voicing of the organ, which is optimized for the melodic treble-range, consequently reduces somewhat the level of the tenor range. In our approach to recording this beautiful instrument, we wanted to present its natural sound as well as its effect in the room. Placing the microphones close to the organ produces the clearest sound, particularly in the tenor range. But this close placement also sounds antiseptic and emphasizes the noise of the keyboard action. If the microphones had been too far away, the organ would have sounded remote, undersized, and muddy. Two DPA omni-directional microphones were carefully placed to capture the instrument’s natural sound on the main floor. The resulting sound is well blended, particularly in the tenor and bass, as the organ sounds in person. The treble is clear and vocal, yet benefits from the acoustical aura of the room. The shortest possible lengths of microphone cable and twenty four-bit analog-to-digital converters captured the minutest detail of the organ and its reverberation in the room.